Surfiest foil ecosystem

If you were starting over today with surf foiling being main priority (with foil drive or riift) which system would you buy into?

Took a while off foiling and now have a riift on order. Starting completely over as I sold everything off. Code was the big name when I stopped and now I see f4 being the new rave. Seems more dw though? Kind of between code, f4, and f one, but would love to hear everyone’s thoughts.

F4 is huge by me for DW and prone, less dominant right now from what I see the assist guys riding. I think that’s pretty telling, but not to say F4 has bad surf wings All their stuff looks like it has great turning while also being glidey pumpy wings. I’ve been thinking of checking them out, but only because I wanna pump a mile while also being able to turn hard.

If I rode assisted, I’d be mostly focused on riding and turning characteristics, and in that space, I think they have lots of competition. Plenty people riding Code assisted, the SK8 has always been super popular for FD. One of the best guys I see on FD rides Gofoil.

With that in mind, I think the gaps between all these aren’t so big when assisted for guys to change kit. That said, if I was buying a brand new setup, I’d take masts, connections, and fuselages into consideration with an eye on the future.

Buying new today? Hydrocraft.

4 Likes

How much do you weigh?

I just proned f4 at 202lbs and it was too wiggly for me when pumping.

Code or Uni if you’re 185+ imo (I haven’t tried the other two brands)

good thread

I would say for more a surfers surf foil the Flux still one of the top based on what I’ve heard from good surfers and based on what is achieved on them. Also Code, Uni, F-one all have surf dedicated foils on their lowest aspect. Add Hydrocraft rampage but I’ve not seen anyone prone it

For a downwinding parawing style I think there are lots, top of mind: F4, Hydrocraft, AFS, but basically everyone is aiming at this surfable all rounder

Given you surf, I’d go the lowest AR possible.. pretty much. I don’t know why people on assists even bother with parawing dw foils

2 Likes

If your local spot has a lot of whitewater you have to pump through, AFS’ silk is probably the best pick imo. The bumps on the leading edge of the front foil handle white water really well.

Regardless, you should definitely demo a system before you buy into it. A wise man once told me: if a brand isn’t willing to put it in your hands for a week-long demo, it’s probably not worth switching to!

F4 has really good re-sale value right now, so you can probably buy a full set and resell it for 80 - 90% of what you paid for it if you don’t love it. (As long as you get one of the popular, high-demand setups orca 685 etc)

5 Likes

What mast where you on? I hear the AX mast isn’t stiff enough. You need GP (or TE or whatever the 13mm mast is) or the super expensive SR mast.

925 piranha, 121xs tail, 75 skinny mast

Oh, yeah. That’s why. Apparently that mast is good, but only for the lighter guys. Not even for me at 185.

I weight 185 and ride the 80AX mast. No flex noticed and no instability or rebound notice.

1 Like

But easier for me to lose 10lbs if i just drinking beers…but thats my one vice.

Losing the weight isn’t easy. Been trying to drop from 185 to 175 for like 4 years. Every time I hit the halfway point at 180 I end up eating too much for like 2 weeks straight!

2 Likes

It seems that everyone has a preference with mast stiffness. It’s pretty clear to me that several key inputs come together here. The person’s weight seem like the most discussed. But it is also pretty clear that wingspan seems to matter a lot too. And the mast length factors too.

I was personally right at the threshold of ok with my 75cm AX mast with orca 685. But with anything with more span it was pretty noticeable. But then again I’m 205lbs. So if you’re 185, I’d guess maybe up to orca 800 will be ok.

Isn’t this where the unlabeled v1 vs v2 ax masts are likely to cause confusion? Quite a few people have said the ax wasn’t there for stiffness, but now there’s a couple different versions in the wild. Still no way to tell one from the other right?

1 Like

Agree here! Grab an AFS skinny 80 UHM and a V2 silk size depending on your weight. I just taught a new foil drive foiler on this setup and he is loving it. Surf focused wing with solid glide and pump. Im flying to fiji tomorrow for a tow trip and all I’m bringing is the V2 Silks.

2 Likes

+1 on weight being a consideration. Not just for stiffness but also for sizing. I’m pushing 230 lbs these days and the code 890x is Goldilocks for me size wise for the one wing surf quiver. There is big hole in current F4 Piranha lineup where my ideal size would be. Even for F-One and Unifoil, my perfect size isn’t made. I’d been going up or down on sizing with different wings, and it worked but once I got the 890x everything else felt like a compromise.

Have you surfed the S series? I can concur that X turns better, but I can pump S so much better. Sometimes, due to the pumping, I’d rather go 850S than 985X (my X foil), because the smaller size gives me the turning, but I don’t lose pump. That all said, I haven’t ridden the 890X or 810X, maybe I can carry speed better on those and pump better even though they are smaller. Who knows?

I own the 850s and 980s. The take off and low speed recovery (grave digging) of the 890x is closer to the 980s than the 850s, while also turning better than the 850s. I find the X to be a more forgiving foil, but some people don’t find themselves in need of forgiveness as often as I do. Span wise the 985x and 850s are really close, so unless you are bigger than me or in really small conditions I can see why you would prefer the 850s. Its just at my weight the easier off makes a difference.

I’m actually much lighter than you at 185lbs. I’m just used to larger foils. I do ride varied conditions… from ankle slappers to chest high. I may give the 890X a shot. I can easily grave dig the 980S. The 985X I find that I have to exit the wave with more speed and keep that speed if I want to succeed. This all said, I’ve been doing that with a slightly chopped 150AR, and I find I prefer smaller tails like the 120R as they help me carry speed better.

I think the best approach when choosing a foil brand is to look at the whole ecosystem rather than just comparing front wings. There are so many excellent foils out there these days, but I think you can narrow things down quite quickly by looking at what each brand does well, and where its limitations are.

A few examples, based on what I’ve owned or tried:

AFS: The Silk is an amazing surf foil, probably one of the best out there. But for my weight and expectations, the 80 UHM standard mast is really the only mast I’d consider. The Skinny is too flexible for me, and their downwind range isn’t nearly as competitive as their surf range, at least compared to what KT, F4 or Axis offer. Of course, if you’re lighter or don’t care about downwind, none of this might be an issue.

FliteLab: I own a Flux 808, and it’s honestly one of the best surf foils I’ve ridden. The control is incredible. Their mast and connection system are excellent too, and their overall platform design is very close to what I’d consider ideal. But the ecosystem is still very limited. They currently have three wing sizes, with three more expected, so six sizes of essentially one surf foil design. No dedicated higher-AR range, no downwind wings, and no really skinny mast option. Maybe all of that will come eventually, but there’s no clear visibility on it for now. If you’re only interested in surf, though, it’s a fantastic option.

F4: Their range looks really promising, especially for downwind. But I tried the Orca with the AX 75 mast, and for me the mast was simply too flexible. I wouldn’t be comfortable using it with something like an 800 or 900 Orca. The RC is a very good mast, but I think there are better options on the market, while the SR is around €3,500, which is a pretty serious investment for a mast alone. So again, great wings, but some compromises depending on your expectations and budget. To be clear, I’ve only personally tested the Orca with the AX 75.

Code Foils: I used to ride Code and really liked the R series. They were extremely easy, although as I progressed I started wanting more performance. I wasn’t completely convinced by the X series, and I eventually left mainly because they took too long to release a proper high-performance mast. At the time, the only real option was the relatively thick UHM mast. Looking at the Black Mast now, I’m not particularly tempted to come back: it’s expensive, and its dimensions aren’t especially impressive to me for downwind.

Axis: Excellent downwind foils, and some great options for parawing too. I’ve owned some of their downwind wings, but eventually found them a bit too technical for my level. And when it comes to pure surf foiling, I don’t think their current range is quite at the level of something like the Silk or Flux.

Unifoil: Their wings look really good, but for me their current mast offering isn’t competitive enough compared with the best options available today. So even though the wings are interesting, I wouldn’t seriously consider the platform right now.

And I’m sure we could do the same exercise with pretty much every brand. None of them is perfect, and what I consider a dealbreaker might be completely irrelevant to someone else.

That’s why I’d suggest starting with a few questions:

  • Which disciplines do you want to cover? Not just what you’re doing today, but what you might want to try in the future. Maybe you’re only surfing now but could get into downwind later. On the other hand, if you know you’ll never be interested in wingfoil racing, there’s no point choosing a brand based on its race foils.

  • What do you expect from your mast? For me, at 95 kg, stiffness is essential, especially with high-AR downwind wings. But I also want the thinnest mast possible for glide and efficiency. That alone eliminates quite a few options.

  • What about the rest of the platform? Fuselage design, connections, materials, modularity, etc. For example, if you don’t want an aluminium fuselage, that’s another easy way to narrow down the choices.

  • Budget and availability: A €3,500 mast might be excellent, but that doesn’t necessarily make it a realistic option. Local distribution, availability of spare parts and pricing also matter.

  • Where is the brand heading? Are they actively developing new wings and improving their platform? Does their roadmap match the disciplines you’re interested in?

Once you’ve gone through all of that, I honestly think you’ll probably end up with just one or two brands that really make sense for you.

And that’s basically how I ended up with KT.

Downwind is my main discipline, so having access to excellent downwind wings was essential. I’m extremely happy with the Solus range, and the Apex mast offers what I consider one of the best combinations of stiffness, low drag and price on the market.

But I also wanted a good surf range, and that’s where the Nomad has been fantastic for me. I’m not an amazing surf foiler, so having an extremely forgiving wing that makes everything easier is a huge advantage. The Nomad has helped me progress a lot, and I still love riding it.

At the same time, if I want something more radical with maximum control, KT has the Halo. I haven’t tried it myself yet, but from the feedback I’ve heard, it seems to offer performance comparable to the Flux.

And with the Nomad V2 and Atlas V2 apparently coming, I’m also quite confident about how the KT range will evolve.

So ultimately, I didn’t choose KT because I think every single KT wing is the best in its category. I chose it because, when I consider the mast, the downwind range, the surf range, the connections, the price and the future development of the platform, it’s the ecosystem that makes the most sense for me.

Someone with a different weight, budget, riding style or ambitions could easily reach a completely different conclusion.

And that’s really my point: rather than asking “What’s the best surf foil?”, I’d start by asking “Which foil ecosystem makes the most sense for everything I want to do?”

Then, once you’ve narrowed it down to one or two brands, choosing the actual wings becomes much easier.

And of course, the X-Files podcast is worth listening to as well. They’ve tested quite a few surf foils and it’s a good way to get different perspectives rather than just relying on everyone’s personal brand preferences here (including mine :sweat_smile:).

18 Likes