So I decided on the Evo 1650 with the Cruiser L stab and HR mast. I’ve had a chance to try it for one session over about 2 hours. I won’t get another chance for a while due to life getting in the way so I thought I’d provide an update with my first impressions. Comparing this against my Axis HPS 1050 and Progressive 425 stab. For reference I’m about 98kgs with wetsuit and helmet, have a windsurfing background, and have probably about 30 sessions under my belt. I’m still working on the gybes, and on a good day, I can do enough dry gybes in a row that my wing dries out.
Speed: Very similar. Comparing my last session on the HPS, my GPS watch tells me there’s 0.1 kts difference in average speed over top five 10 second runs (12.2 kts vs 12.1), with the Evo being faster, but obviously this is well within the margin for error. Subjectively, the Evo feels more comfortable at speed (fewer vibration/wobbles) and I think there’s more potential to find.
Glide: The Evo feels glidier, but it’s also less front-foot heavy than the HPS, so this is still limited by me rather than the foil because I keep touching down too soon due to my own poor pitch control. Looking forward to trying to get more out of it.
Lift: The Evo lifts significantly earlier. I think there’s 1.5-2 knots board speed difference in it, maybe more, which is significant because I’m taking off at something like 5-6 knots instead of 7-8. So early that initially I wasn’t expecting it to lift and thought I was still in the process of getting the board moving. The HPS also pitches up a lot right before stall, which the Evo doesn’t do anywhere near as much, so I’m less likely to get the foil up and then immediately stall it again by failing to control the pitch. On first try, this feels like the biggest difference between the two foils. It enabled me to change down to a smaller hand wing than I’d normally use in those conditions.
Turning: No less agile than the HPS despite a slightly larger span. In fact, it feels like it’s more agile, but I’m not the right person to be pushing the turns hard yet. Initial feeling is that doing big and small S turns the Evo feels a bit happier and for me, more controllable.
Other differences in no general order: The Evo is lighter, quieter, stiffer & has less vibrations through chop etc, seems to handle breeches better (I only breeched once and didn’t immediately crash), and I think assembly & disassembly is a bit easier.
Keen to get more time on it and keep learning it. I’ll update if my opinions change. Before getting it, I was curious about what I’d find, and wasn’t sure whether I’d have a massive revalation like FrequentFaller in the thread above, or whether I’d be disappointed. Summary is that I’m pretty happy: firstly because I feel like the AFS system will support me better as I grow with smaller Evo’s and Enduros (which is one of the reasons I made the change anyway), and secondly because it has significantly earlier lift with the same or incrementally better performance in all other aspects. So very keen to get out on it again and it’s just unfortunate timing that I probably won’t be out again for 6 weeks or more.